Qantas, Woolworths and Virgin snared in executive hunting season

Banducci stormed out of an interview for the program having made a remark about former Competition and Consumer Commission chair Rod Sims which he clearly regretted, but which the interviewer refused to consign to the cutting room floor.

Tempting as it is to suggest Banducci’s departure is a direct result of his inability to take control of the narrative, it probably isn’t the main reason, or even a significant part of the reason.

The Woolworths chairman’s explanation that Banducci and the board had been talking about succession for more than six months and the supermarket giant began screening candidates late last year is plausible.

That said, the precise timing of the announcement of Banducci’s departure and the appointment of his successor Amanda Bardwell does feel like it has got corporate communications fingerprints all over it. If it looks like the government has won a scalp, it could dilute Canberra’s regulatory invective – every little bit helps.

That said, it does seem we have entered the corporate twilight zone when a chief executive is punished for earning investors too much and has to explain that the strength of his company’s profit margins has nothing to do with overcharging for store food and groceries.

Loading

There is one line in Woolworths’ profit announcement that I have never seen before in many years of reporting results: “We are focused on helping our customers spend less every time they shop with us.” That’s a new take on corporate capitalism.

Woolworths’ critics (the government, one cohort of customers and a couple of former ACCC chairmen) should be pleased to see that food and grocery inflation is moderating (down to 1.3 per cent in the second quarter), that the outlook for this year’s profit looks weaker than expected and Banducci is promising to tackle shelf prices with more vigour.

Meanwhile, the replacement of Goyder as Qantas chairman was one of the most anticipated personnel decisions in decades.

The disgraced airline’s board needed an injection of experience and corporate gravitas – which they will have with John Mullen taking the big chair around the board table. Mullen has brought with him Nora Scheinkestel, a fellow director at Brambles, to ride shotgun.

Qantas’ woes stem from a similar place to those of Woolworths, in some respects.

Qantas, too, has found itself in hot water with claims it was over-earning at the expense of customers. The record $2.5 billion profit the airline made last year came off the back of elevated airfares, underinvestment in its fleet and diminished customer service, to say nothing of choking its customers’ ability to redeem frequent flyer points.

While the former chief executive Alan Joyce was pinged as the main culprit, the board of directors fell into line behind him thus allowing the tail to wag the dog.

Since Joyce’s departure in September, Qantas’ new chief executive Vanessa Hudson has promised to spend money on a whole raft of measures aimed at improving customer service, bettering on-time performance and reducing flight cancellations.

Loading

Just how much profit she is prepared to sacrifice for this will become clearer when Qantas announces its results later this week.

The final high-profile executive churn to make headlines this week was the departure of Virgin boss Jayne Hrdlicka, which probably has more to do with under-earning than over-earning.

Virgin’s ownership masters at private equity firm Bain appear to be underwhelmed by Virgin’s recent performance in what was meant to be the lead-up to its sharemarket float.

Virgin had a window to list last year after it inked a strong result, but didn’t climb through it. Being an unlisted company we don’t have good visibility into how its profit is now tracking. But government-collated information showing cancellation rates and on-time performance isn’t looking rosy.

With several key executives that were crucial to the IPO having recently departed, Virgin’s timetable for a float in May now sits on a scale between wildly optimistic and dead.

You can’t have an IPO without a CEO.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.